Unelected Labour Lords threaten to block new #ScotlandBill powers for Scotland


Labour group plans to oppose devolving abortion when Lords scrutinise proposals

THE SCOTLAND BILL could be delayed in the House of Lords due to Labour members blocking the devolution of abortion to the Scottish Parliament.

According to The Herald , a “group of Labour peers hope to set back” the proposal, which won the support of a majority of MPs in the House of Commons this week.

One source, speaking to the newspaper, confirmed that: “There is time to canvas opinion and support” ahead of the Lords debate on the legislation.

Delaying tactics could cause havoc for the Bill, as no single party has a majority in the House of Lords.

Instead Labour – whose MPs voted against devolving abortion to Scotland – could play a crucial role in delaying the Scotland Bill and requesting that the proposals are watered down further.

However, any such move would risk criticism of the unelected chamber – which has no members representing Scottish electors and where Scotland’s largest party, the SNP, is unrepresented.

An SNP spokesperson told The Herald: “The House of Lords is an affront to democracy. The idea that it will hamper the delivery of any aspect of the Scotland Bill to the people of Scotland will only add to the sense that it is an expensive outdated chamber of cronies, donors and ermine-clad hangers-on.”

From 2010-15, 62 members of the House of Lords who didn’t vote once claimed PS360,000 in expenses. Last year the House of Lords cost PS93.1m, PS118,000 per member.

The devolution of abortion was a rare substantial amendment to the Scotland Bill at stage two of its parliamentary debate.

Labour MPs, most notably former minister Yvette Cooper, raised fears that devolving abortion could lead to fewer women’s rights in either Scotland or England.

Emma Ritch, executive director of Engender, said that the organisation does see “the possibility for a more progressive law in Scotland” having previously raised concern over a lack of consultation on the issue.

SNP MP Deidre Brock said it was insulting to argue that Scotland needed “male dominated Westminster to protect women’s rights” in Scotland.

The Scottish Government has committed to leaving abortion rights unchanged were they to be devolved.

The House of Lords will discuss the Scotland Bill in the coming months.

Picture courtesy of House of Lords